"Wall Of Noise" excellent in theory. In practice, not so much.
Replies
I wish I was left with a sense of mystery and longing, instead of this bad taste in my mouth.
That said, there is nothing like it in the world as far as the actual physical sensation. Like getting an all over vibrating massage, like into your chest cavity and your toes. I wonder how bad that could be to the brain?
Holy crap. I was there last night.
Needless to say, I left early. I could not enjoy the fact that I was not discerning any music.
My ears are still fucking ringing. Why did they not have this at the Greek?
Yeah. The concourse is a great EXHIBITION hall. I think, though, it should be banned from holding actual music concerts, ever again. It's notorious for being a horrible venue, and yet promoters still continue to book. This was my first time there for a show, so I really didn't know. Now I sure as hell won't be back.
The sound was all muddy (which for MBV is dissonant enough to begin with, you need that clarity.) Kevin Shield's guitar sounded 2 notes too high and a half a second off. I didn't even recognize some songs initially. Sad, considering how expensive the tickets were, and how ravingly awesome the reviews were for other cities.
And not to mention it was a really bad first impression for someone who rarely knew the band. And yet, I didn't see many people trying to exit around 11:30. Maybe some people enjoyed it...
I felt kind of blinded and headachy.
@lady: I wish I knew you were going!
But yeah, so much better to just get Loveless, put your headphones on and crank it up, lie down on your own bed, rocking out with perfect clarity, precision and solitude.
That's so awful that the sound was bad. The band bought hundreds of thousands of dollars' worth of new sound equipment for this tour. The insane volume is required for the physical sensation of the sound waves that makes it such a "you had to be there, no recording could accurately document what it was like" experience -- but it actually sounds better with good earplugs.
I saw their last night in New York, and I saw them in Providence and Boston in '92. They're a hugely important band to me, and I was worried that my memory of them was so augmented by nostalgia that seeing them again could only be a disappointment -- but the truth is, this time around was actually better.
As a side note, it's no coincidence that the first time I saw them was also the last show I ever attended without earplugs.
@sodoff
That's awesome, but it made me feel even more sorry for myself. After all, I had only waited FIFTEEN YEARS for this! sigh. Their other shows got insanely glowing reviews, that it made the disappointment of mine all the more apparent. (like this one: http://blog.mlive.com/mediumfidelity/2008/09/my_bloody_valentine_creates_bl.html ) I never blamed the band for one second, knowing how much of a perfectionist KS is.
They're hugely important to me, as well. It was from being introduced to them that pretty much reformed my taste in music around that time and discovered bands like lush, chapterhouse (old style), verve, catherine wheel, slowdive, cocteau twins etc. I was truly the shoegaze poster child with my hanging bangs, black tights, droopy sweaters... well, some things never change I suppose ;)
At this show they passed out earplugs at the gate. You'd have to be insane not to wear them. I like to flirt with danger, though, so I keep them with the barest amount of high end seeping in. I did take one off out of curiosity for just a moment, and thought um NO, and promptly reseated that sucker.
I saw them in 91 when they did the wall of noise thing for about 15 minutes. Mellow stoned Texans started wigging out.
Too bad the sound sucked.
I would have loved it. But then, I have a lot of Merzbow in my music collection.
those New York shows, were BRUTAL.
people say Manowar are the loudest band in the world
NUH UH!!!!
@LO> I thought I saw you in line! But I didn't want to shout, "HEY LO!" and look like a doofus if it wasn't you.
I have never previously worn earplugs to a concert but, I did for half of this. I would not say that MBV was unusually loud, volume wise. It was higher pitched, which does more damage. They had very little by way of bass and sub-bass.
@Machined & Kahn: you are probably correct on all counts.
@retro joe: I thought certain sound elements were overwhelmed, but then you can't ignore that every fiber of your being was shaking at the end.
@Oom: there was a good strata of haze at this show, too. No one was particularly wiggy, (SF'ans are used to much weirder) though there were those few VERY enthusiastic dancers. I mean, really? Puttin all you got into MBV? There are a few quite bouncy songs, but still.
@0fuck: I think the show that claimed about 20% on my left ear was slowdive in Toronto. In fact, THIS very show. It was one of the last few times I ever felt that "OMG I cannot believe that this is really happening, I am so blissed I could die right now!" feeling.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cNzK-PGLENU
enjoy. ;)
@nomi> If bone shaking noise were all I wanted, I could have hung around SFO.
@nomi - damn! you saw Slowdive, Mao saw MBV. . .yikes.
nobody danced at the NYC show except this one kid I know (who was up front and I did not run into him all night), and me. . .I was in back (like the pansy I am).
Hah, I was being really disgusting in line. Its okay if you would have been embarrassed to call me out.

especially in a former railyard with carpeting and bad acoustics.
especially when it lasts OVER TEN MINUTES.
Then, it's bordering on the absurd.
Since it's not really anything "new" merely a rehashing of something for nostalgia.
For those of you who do not know what a "wall of noise" is...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FpXTn0Dd1SQ