Can anyone explain to me why posting hatespeach on the internet is considered funny? I just don't get it.
Replies
BECAUSE THEY'RE ALL "SERIOUS BUSINESS" AND YOU'RE ALL "LAAAAWWWWLLLL"
And if you are saying racist and sexist and homophobic and anti-Semetic things in real life, why is anyone around to listen to you?
@mizsarah: He's referring to the stupid, stupid troll ethos that nothing said online actually matters.
Myself, I think the reason is, as always, ascribable to John Gabriel's Greater Internet Fuckwad Theory. http://www.penny-arcade.com/comic/2004/03/19/
Maybe I've lived in California too long, but I still think that the words we use matter. I have a great sense of humor, but it doesn't extend to hurting people knowingly.
I think it's funny that I'm much more "epithetically" reserved online than I am in real life.
Probably has to do with me being uneducated, the subhumans I choose to fraternize with, the ill-breeding which I received and my place of residence being northern New Jersey.
On the other hand, I think the pseudo intelligentsia who frequent online forums to exchange their “ideas” with one another find it “ironic” to punctuate their positions with such off color commentary.
I don't agree with the trolls. Context needs to be taken into account and even IF it's a forum that traffics heavily in insults, hatespeech belies a lack for intelligence and creativity.
Maybe some members of the gti community (whether or not you self-idetify as a troll) can explain why they do it?
I mean, if you just want attention, I'll give you attention. I don't have to dislike you to do that.
@mizsarah: please see my post above. i really think that's a big reason as to why many "cut loose" online.
all of it... in its essence, these individuals look at the internet as an arena where they are the boss and their humor is king.
It's their own little way of "being funny." They find it funny, their peers find it funny and strangers who share the same views find it funny - so it continues.
Ever been on line (not online hahaha) for an event and witnessed a group of DOUCHEBAGS being addressed by some alpha-fuck in the group and they're all captive to his stupid fucking story about ESPN Sports Center or The Colbert Report? The lead douche puts his spin on it, makes it no funnier than it already WASN'T and they're laughing like mad.
I get embarrassed by those situations. I get embarrassed by them online, which is why I choose not to partake in conversations where people call each other chinks, honkies, inbred-serial-killer-sister-fucking-rednecked-wet-dog-smelling-snowflakes, coons, micks, spics, hicks, camel jockeys, injuns, dotheads, coons or anything else of that ilk.
I look at the real world as a suitable forum in which to use such colloquialisms.
I hope no one's noticed, but I'm angry. Really angry. Probably closer to seething, boiling mad and fucking pissed, actually. All that hatespeech masquerading as wit angers me, the fact that I can't do anything but ignore or deal with it frustrates me, and that it has gone on for so long fills me with a great agonizing despair. And I try not to mention or show it, because if I did, I'm pretty sure that the trolls would be amused.
So yeah. Now that I've gone and betrayed my ugly little secret, I'll be at the bar.
Sorry for the double coon inclusion. I meant to put in something for the Jews.
Anyhow, I am surely no choir boy with regard to online conduct, but the allure of escape is a major impetus for people's misbehaving.
If you knew me in real life, you'd see that I'm a very timid soul when it comes to the more seductive side of the human experience yet when I am online I am an unabashed, wanton, libertine WHORE!!!
@l&r, I think I get what you're saying now.
The only excuses I can think of for the behavior you describe are either a Carlin-esqe "there are no forbidden words", which I understand in a 1st amendment kinda way. I get that the response to bad speech isn't censorship, but good speech. Or maybe I can see a "reclaiming" the words understanding, like bringing back Chick and Queer. I for one want to bring back "heifer", but only because I really thing B*tch is played out.
Heifer is a sacred term that provides nothing but animalistic AROUSAL as it conjures up visions of healthy hindquarters ready for the WRANGLING.
YUM YUM
I'm always interested in the contrast between people who are offended by this behavior, and people who aren't. It doesn't seem to make sense.
i think often it's tossed about to illustrate it's utter absurdity, but other times it's meant seriously. it's hard to differentiate sometimes, but i find that certain people can be relied upon for hate speech and others just find adding another "offensive" statement to the mix to be an illustrative tool of silliness.
for instance, in the "death to hipsters" thread, hating on any group is just stupid. ginger chose to illustrate that with the jews, which granted, is perhaps a risky choice, but her comment isn't really that different from mine about hating third graders.
it's all unfounded.
@Sven - have you been able to hypothesize anything about who gets put out and who doesn't? Is it an age difference thing, or a regional one, or income-based or something?
See, I have it from a very good source that you are, IRL, a real sweetie. But sometimes you say things that I just don't understand (though not as much lately that I've seen). I never understood the contrast.
Any ladies wearing or driving some WRANGLERS around right now? Please, stick with me here... new FANTASY.
I am one of those people who behaves exactly the same way IRL that I do online.
I hate everyone, basically, until they prove not to be an idiot. But if the non-idiot happen to be part of a certain group, that doesn't mean that the whole group is relieved of idiot status.
The difference between me and h8rs is that even though I hate everyone, I won't say anything about it until they do something to piss me off. Everytime I go to a club in ftl, some Haitian guy thinks its okay to rub his junk all up on me. That is NOT okay, so I talk shit about hating Haitians.
@pepper - I didn't see your 3rd graders comment until you mentioned it, but it seemed to be doing the same thing that others were doing, i.e., covering up for (ironic?) anti-semitism by treating it as a joke and being and playing along to a lesser extent. I mean, no one actually thinks you hate 8 year olds.
But I was waiting for a non-Jew to stand up for me and say that it isn't funny so I don't have to be the kill-joy. Confidentially to Tanya, I love you, but money-stealing jokes aren't working for me.
I feel very insulted that you would believe I really think the Jews stole my money. While we're on the subject. I should feel insulted that someone said I stole THEIR money.
If I really thought that, I wouldn't have left my purse with Pepper while singing karaoke the other night.
Also, I think most of the people here who use "hate speech" ironically think it's okay because they make fun of their own groups as well.
Personally, I think it's all in good fun. I know it twists up peoples panties but to say that, but I generally keep my off-color comments restricted to the threads belonging to people on my team who are familiar with my sense of humor.
I'm not sure that's what you're trying to do at all. I think you are trying to express that something upset you and you want an apology.
Pepper hit the nail on the head explaining my thought process and the joke. Do I go over the top? Yes. But I think hating and wishing death on any large group of strangers is pretty over the top.
For instance, earlier I pointed out the white stereotype of Orange County would want the latino stereotype of Celisse's people to do their yardwork. I guarantee you she did not shed one tear, nor contemplated whether I really thought so little of those people.
I have to say, I'm glad to hear from you that you're not serious.
Am I upset? Yes, I am. 'Cause it ain't funny to me. It's not an apology I want, it's a better place to talk to my friends. I think if you ask around, people here will tell you that I'm not the type to try and make your life any worse. Why would you want to do that to me?
I don't think I'm making anyone's life worse by making jokes with people whom I consider friends.
Well, if you want to stop making my life worse, you could lighten up. But you probably won't. The mere fact you feel this way about my sense of humor and that you want to censor me and what I have to say, well... it makes me feel like a 2nd class citizen.
I hear the Ntsh is very PC though.
@johnny, don't tell her the stuff I've said about you being black. I'm gonna go delete that thread about the r'ing of little girls.
the hell are you talking about?
are the two biggest haters on the site hating on each other for being haters? or...what? what the fuck is going on?
We can talk in notes if you'd prefer I didn't call you out in a public forum. I didn't mention your name at all - I was just trying to understand the racism-is-now-funny mindset everywhere. Call it PC if you want, but it's really the way I think and act. I don't think censorship needs to enter into it.
Well, obviously I don't mind saying ANYTHING on a public forum. And obviously I am serious about stuff a less than 2% of the time.
i wasn't covering up for anti-semitism... if i thought it was serious on any level i would have said something. why would it be different to assume that i hate third-graders than to assume that ginger actually hates jews?
the only difference is that historically people have had hatred for jews, and there's no precedent for people hating school-aged children... but that doesn't make it untrue or impossible.
i find the sterotype that jews are money stealers laughable, just as i find most sterotypes. i actually do a "jewish" burlesque number to the song "money- it's what i want." but that's because i know it's not true.
I, personally, do hate third graders. And first graders. And ALL smelly middle schoolers.
Maybe it's just more obvious to me that Kendra's joking than that Tiff is because I've met her in real life. And because, as she says, there isn't a 2,000 year precedent for hating 3rd graders.
The stereotypes might seem laughable to us, but I swear to you that there are people who still believe them. I once had someone step 3 feet away from me when they learned I was Jewish because they literally thought lighting would strike me for not believing in Jebus.
I personally hate judging people by grade level. because everyone knows everyone younger than college level is an idiot.
plus I've always been 10 years more mature than my age. I dare someone to prove me wrong.
of course there are still people who believe stereotypes- there probably always will be.
the only thing to do in that case is calmly explain why they should reconsider- to get upset about it not only gives them power, but makes you feel shitty.
holding on to anger is like clutching a hot coal with the intent of throwing it at someone else- you are the one who is burned.
I think this topic got way more serious than it should have been. You people are uptight and hostile.
I'm coming in to this one kinda late, so I don't have much to say that wasn't said up above. I think that our words do matter, and that we should make an effort to be considerate without giving away the right to be a little snarky.
There is a difference between a witty remark and a jab, and it's in our best interest to make this forum a place where friendly conversation can proceed. Also, stereotypes are nobody's friend, even in jest.
@mizsarah - Actually I thought she was making some sort of comment with regards to hating on one group of people and making venting commentary about hipsters & steampunks is one quick shot away from racist humor, therefore not cool at all. I may have misunderstood Ginger's intention. My comment did not really contribute anything positive, but I'm sure it would have been better, had I said anything at all, if I said "Well the Jews hate you because you don't like gefelte fish."
well, yeah. how could you not love *obnoxious sweeping hand motion* all this?
*sigh* No one likes gefelte fish. It's just an excuse to eat more horseradish.
p.s. xoxo
So who's the victim here again? 'Cause this sounds like another round of Oppression Olympics.
Well, I do like when all the kosher goods go on sale really cheap after passover.
We're all a little Jewish in a way.
PS: While it's a stereotype, my basis for it comes from my experience with some Russian-Jewish immigrants, to whom money IS a serious big deal and one of the more important ambitions in life, whether the having of it or the process of attanining it. But that's probably completely separate from their ethnic/religious heritage, and entirely to do with the economic and social hardships that many Russian immigrants experienced in the past.
AKA: "WTF, you're an art major? What kind of money can you earn with that?"
AKA: "What does your boyfriend do & how much does he make?"
AKA: "How much did that cost?"
AKA: Check out this expensive (insert vacation/car/jewelry/house/whatever) I just got.
I hate that shit and I see it a lot and it bothers me
@ginger - I will bake you the biggest batch of ruggelach and mandelbrot and babka and all other sorts of tasty Jewish cookies with funny names if it will get you to understand even a tiny bit where I'm coming from. I'm not trying to call you a racist, I'm just saying that racist language isn't a funny joke, especially in text, where no one can catch the body language clues that you're joking. 'Sgood?
Sarah, is babka the noodle dish? My mom used to make a babka all the time, with spaghetti noodles and raisins.
No, kugel is the noodle dish (which I just went out and got ingredients for yesterday, hint hint). Babka is a kind of chocolate filled cake/bread thing. It ain't half bad either.
P.s. - did your dad like the brandied cherries? Or did you eat them all yourself?
Basketball teams have mostly black dudes. Why? I mean, I know there's that stereotype of them being more athletic or whatever. But stereotypes never have any reality to them, right?
I haven't been over to the house yet. The jar is unopened on my nightstand. It won't go bad right?
This is the one i"m talking about: http://www.bigoven.com/102754-Joy-Philbins-Noodle-Pudding-recipe.html
It's called Babka in some Eastern European cultures I guess?
Wait this one is better. No cottage cheese (yuck) but you DO wanna add raisins. http://www.tasteofhome.com/Recipes/Babka--Noodle-Pudding-
All I know is, I can't control other people's commentary, but I can control how I react to it.
I also think it's good that not everyone laughs at the same jokes, because even though I don't have a big problem with racist, homophobic, sexist jokes... I do think it's good to talk about and understand why some people might be bothered by them.
I also don't mind explaining myself as long as it means not having to censor myself.
I don't understand where you're going with this. Are you just outraged with me that I got upset? Do you want real answers to the basketball question, or are you trying to make some sort of a point?
(Feeding the masses is a secret strategy for pacifying tempers during heated discussions)
I think ultimately Sarah doesn't want an apology, but she wants to be understood WHY she's upset?
@bizzy - s'okay darlin, your point is well taken.
@tanya - nope, that's still a kugel in my book.
@sarah: We always called it babka :) I didn't know kugel until I came here.
also, babka is a part of mechanism in machine, but its a rare sort of meaning and its hardly used by anyone, except for professionals, I guess.
Which begs the question - WHO on earth would want to eat something that is named after an old lady?
hey Stereo... you speak Russian, yes?
If so, is this Софья the correct way to spell the equivalent of "Sophie?"
Because I prefer other feelings? That's a strange question to ask. I mean, anger is one thing, but even then it is really, really quickly gone and out of my system. I've sort of grown out of letting other people control the way I feel. Also, I feel you regret a lot of the things you say and do when you're angry. You never really convey what you mean and who actually takes into consideration what someone ragin' has to say?
oh, shut up with your googling nonsense, stereotest. you're a fucking tool.
@ginger - you have a point there. I did just make myself go back and read the things I posted when my heartrate was high and my hands were shaky to see if I was out of line.
I'm almost never angry. Really, I have a long fuse.
But outrage isn't the same thing as anger, and I think it can be more useful. Why wouldn't we want to change things for the better if we had the chance?
I don't think outrage or anger ever changes anything for the better. I'm getting a lot more from you as a calm and not-so-angry person than I did before.
I really did start this trying to understand it calmly.
But I have to go pick up my car at the shop before it closes, so I won't be able to continue the conversation until later this evening. Can we talk more about this then?
I think bizzy summed it up pretty well.
I come from the school where what you say matters, and how you present what you say matters, and if you're an asshole, it comes right on out.
But I also know where I'm unwelcome because of this, so I try to monitor my own, and no more. You can call others out all you want, they will listen only if they want to. There are a million ways to defend your behavior, especially if it's rewarded in any manner.
That doesn't mean you shouldn't speak your heart of course, but as they say, you pick your battles.
Recommended reading: http://www.racialicious.com/2008/07/23/the-delusion-of-hatred-immunity/#more-1769
An excerpt:
At the heart of much satire and all bad satire, is something snarky and holier-than-thou, the belief that when someone (allegedly) enlightened articulates the exact same thing as someone unenlightened, it’s different solely because of the mouth it comes out of. Underpinning this kind of satire is often classism, ignorance and a pretty gross lack of self-awareness.
I'm out. Bizzy, you're in charge til I get back, since you seem to have the middle ground. And because you're so damn cute.
I actually do too. I just wanted to keep down the contention wherever possible.
the only gifelte fish i ever had was made by my late grandmother. it had a weird gelatenous tomato sauce and bones in it. it tasted like if canned tuna went on vacation to italy and came back trying to be all fancy, and all the other tunas are like, you're still the same damn tuna, just in tomato sauce. ciao!

I mean, if you wouldn't say something out loud in public because it's offensive, why would you type it here?